Raising the Bar, according to Wikipedia, garnered 7.7 million viewers on it’s series premiere. It’s easy to understand why with the influence of the recent writer’s strike, America is dying for some original TV this fall. While a few programs have returned, and some have odd seasons (like Eureka from SciFi which started in July), we’re still waiting for the bulk of our much beloved programming to return. September marks the start of that with season freshman Raising the Bar which aired along side returning series Prison Break. Metacritic is where I go for my homogenized reviews and has some excellent quotes about just how bad the program really is.
At this time, Raising the Bar managed a 48/100 from the professional critics and a 1.5/10 from the insignificant number of amature critics/users.
The best review was quoted as:
Good show with fine cast, but it all still feels a little too familiar and old-fashioned. — Newsday 75/100
My girlfriend said something out of the ordinary for her, and in retrospect, hilarious: “There are no beautiful people in this cast.”
When you stop to think about it, not a single one of the actors were cast for their striking physical appeal. This sets the program apart (and above the rest in some respects) for trying to set the stage with ‘ordinary’ looking people, but ordinary is exactly how the program comes across. Ordinary and contrived.
The first two episodes (I’ve seen the first and the previews for the second, and read the reviews of the second episode) appear to use the same formula: Defendant on trial, Protagonist Lawyer defending them, Antagonist Judge gets her feelings hurt by the young stud defender, Judge sentences defendant to maximum sentence to teach young stud a lesson, gay clerk for the judge screws judge to get her to be more reasonable.
The martyrd gay clerk (screwing THE (wo)MAN to help his straight friend who keeps running afoul of the judge) was a twist I didn’t see coming, but it’s as contrived as the rest of the show, since we don’t understand why he would do such thing, and what’s more, we don’t understand how the judge can get away with it (violating the rights of defendent and lawyer without reprisal, and engaging in a sexual relationship with a subordinate without consequence) in more than one episode without being turned in to the Bar Association or landing on the front page of the news.
Frankly, I think the whole reason the judge has it out for the young stud lawyer is because she’s got the hots for him and he turned her down (it’s as contrived as the rest of the show and would fit the current theme) so now she’s out to teach him a lesson for spurning her advances.
Needless to say, I won’t be watching this again.